Joe , definitely go with the one you would be the happiest with and the one which would give you the most job satisfaction, even if it was a bit less money to start off with. Remember this is something that you will spend much of your life doing and you want it to be an enjoyable experience during that time.
Years ago I was a Tool & Diemaker at GM, I was not really happy with my job, even though it had excellent pay, excellent benefits and great pension.
I looked around and found a job in the Nuclear Industry, I decided to quit my good job and go to this even though it was a drop in pay for a couple of years. Well it was the best move I ever did because I was happy with my work, I enjoyed going and eventually my wages were right at the top again. I never did tire of the job yet I got to retire at the age of 53.
Good luck on your decision.