Difference between slotted and cross drilled rotors

ocal21

iS VIP
iS VIP
Location
Boston, MA
Car
2012 FX35
Name
Oscar
Im thinking about purchasing stop tech rotors with new brake lines and new braked pads since i prob wont be doing the BBK anytime soon.

The question i have which i can't seem to find anywhere what is the difference between cross drilled rotors and slotted rotors? Then they have slotted/cross drilled rotors. Some advice will be appreciated thanks.
 
fwiw next time around I think I'm going to go slotted only, not drilled and slotted. drilled make the brakes stop slightly better & looks better too I think, but they wear the brakes faster too. for performance I think slots alone are enough really, drilled also can start to develop stress cracks around the chamfered holes if abused too...
 
slotted
sp_slotted_bg.jpg

Cross Drilled
sp_drilled_bg.jpg

Slotted/Cross Drilled
sp_drilled_slotted_bg.jpg
 

Attachments

  • sp_slotted_bg.jpg
    sp_slotted_bg.jpg
    60 KB · Views: 26
  • sp_drilled_bg.jpg
    sp_drilled_bg.jpg
    56.9 KB · Views: 28
  • sp_drilled_slotted_bg.jpg
    sp_drilled_slotted_bg.jpg
    55.6 KB · Views: 28
fwiw next time around I think I'm going to go slotted only, not drilled and slotted. drilled make the brakes stop slightly better & looks better too I think, but they wear the brakes faster too. for performance I think slots alone are enough really, drilled also can start to develop stress cracks around the chamfered holes if abused too...


so you think slotted rotors might be a little better the cross drilled? Im just trying to figure out what would be the best ones. Some places say cross drilled others say slotted and others say plain rotors so i figured to ask FX drivers here.
 
slotted is enough to out gas the brakes & keep the pad surface clean without being like a cheese grater, slots are more like "slicing/shaving" rather than "grating" & less aggressive wear overall for the rotor & pad... blanks are the least aggressive but fade easily when heated up, best for a commuter car that will be used conservatively, if you always drive conservatively then the blanks will last the longest, but for spirited driving at least I'd say get the slotted
 
slotted is enough to out gas the brakes & keep the pad surface clean without being like a cheese grater, slots are more like "slicing/shaving" rather than "grating" & less aggressive wear overall for the rotor & pad... blanks are the least aggressive but fade easily when heated up, best for a commuter car that will be used conservatively, if you always drive conservatively then the blanks will last the longest, but for spirited driving at least I'd say get the slotted

+1

I run drilled and slotted, just because I think it "looks" cool. I've actually read that blanks are the best, because it creates the most surface area for friction.

Drilled = creates "invisible" hairline fractures regardless of how you drill it. This makes it more prone to stress fractures. Porsche actually CASTS their rotors with holes and are not drilled, this is the way to go but cost a lot and no known manufacturer even offers this as an option. Helps avoid warping too with more cooling due to the holes.

Drilled also gets brake dust stuck in the cooling vanes of the internal side of the rotor -- most will get cleared away but I guess it still adds the possibility of build up. Almost all companies recommend plain or slotted for "severe" or "track" driving.

Slotted = quicker initial bite because lets gasses escape -- if the slots are done right... and the slot goes all the way to the edge of the rotor. Slightly reduces pad life, but also keeps them clean by "deglazing" them at each pass, especially as the rotor wears out and the slots get sharper... They also create a sound when braking -- which I love because you can "hear" the car stopping. Some might find this an annoyance.

Drilled and slotted = pros and cons of having drilled and slotted, but even less surface area.

Official Porsche cars that come with cast holes are still replaced with blanks when they are on the track.

In a perfect world, I would only get slotted only, but cross drilled looks too good for me to pass up.
 
FWIW, I have the Stoptech BBK, cross drilled only. They are as silent as OEM and the pads are less than 30% worn after a year. The BBK rotor is bigger than OEM, so additional surface area is available for pad contact, but they still produce more dust than OEM.

Rear setup is OEM size cross drilled rotors with Hawk pads - lots of brake dust - more than the fronts.

In terms of performance the stock setup is fine for daily driving. If you track or push the car for more than a few minutes at a time, I agree with Turbocad that slotted is more than enough to address cooling and resistance to hot fade.
 
Back
Top