I'd agree, I mean not going to start digging in with 500 to take out a light scuff, but if the headlight is already gouged deep or oxidized enough to be yellowed then your left with 3 choices, cut past the damage, live with the damage, or replace...
some headlights like some benzes have a protective layer that you will actually be able to see when you cut through it, it looks almost like when you break through a clearcoat & will leave a distinct ring around the broken through layer, but most aren't like that from what I've delt with...
like anything else though, best to start with least agressive & least invasive proceadure & work your way up to what turns out to be just enough to do the job, rather than to just attack something too agressively or 2 invasive & do more harm than good...