Welcome to InfinitiScene.com - Home for Infiniti QX and Q enthusiasts!
You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access to the forums. Why not register on our forums and gain the extra benefits that our regular members enjoy?

  • Enthusiast Owned and Operated!
  • Registraion is free.
  • You will be able to post, message, and interact with other members.
  • Our forum is full of friendly, knowledgeable members and staff.
  • Plenty of money saving opportunities from write-ups to maintenance help.
  • Create a garage and show off your ride and specs.
  • Opportunity for ad-free viewing.
  • Plus much more!

Registration is fast, free, and easy, so stop being just a guest and become one of our newly registered members today!

[OT] OT: G35 Worst in Low Impact Crashes

Discussion in 'Off-Topic' started by r0bert0e, Aug 2, 2007.

  1. r0bert0e

    r0bert0e Member

    Likes Received:
    Hopefully, the FX doesn't follow the G35's footsteps in this test.


    Luxury car, crummy bumper

    Insurance group's low-speed crash tests reveal weaknesses in cars' first line of defense.

    By Peter Valdes-Dapena, CNNMoney.com staff writer
    August 2 2007: 9:30 AM EDT

    NEW YORK (CNNMoney.com) -- In tests designed to replicate low-speed impacts, the bumpers of several luxury cars failed to prevent costly damage. In one case, a Mercedes-Benz C-class sedan sustained almost $5,500 in damage when hit in its front bumper at a speed of just 6 miles per hour.
    The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety conducted four separate low-speed impact tests on 11 popular luxury cars.
    The cars struck a barrier, designed to mimic the bumper of another car, straight-on from the front and from the rear at six miles per hour and diagonally into front and rear corners at three miles per hour. The Institute, a private organization funded by insurance companies, estimated repair costs after each test.
    "[W]hat the test results don't reflect is the Mercedes-Benz holistic approach to occupant safety," Mercedes-Benz said in a statement. "This philosophy influences design and development even down to the front bumper, which is specifically mounted lower to help reduce injury for impacts with pedestrians (to avoid contact above the knee)."
    The C-class performed poorly in large part because its front bumper slid down below the impact barrier during the test.
    The vehicle sustaining the most total damage was the Infiniti G35, made by Nissan, which had total estimated repair costs of $14,000. In the straight-on front impact test alone, the G35 sustained $5,223 in damage.
    "The cost of vehicle ownership and repair are important considerations at Infiniti," Nissan said in a statement. "We design each new model to resist low-speed collision damage and will continue to work closely with major insurance companies to keep premiums low for our customers."
    The Insurance Institute's tests do not reflect likely real-world results, Nissan said.
    The best-performing vehicle in the test was the Saab 9-3. Its total estimated repair costs for all four tests was $5,243, less than what the Mercedes-Benz would have cost to fix after just one front impact.
    The Institute wasn't enthusiastic about even the Saab's performance in these tests, however.
    "There's nothing exemplary about even the best performer, the Saab 9-3," said vice president Joe Nolan in a statement. "It simply avoided racking up the most damage in any single test and ended up coming out the best in a mediocre lot."
    Saab said in a statement that it was proud of the 9-3's top-ranked performance in these tests.
    In an earlier round of tests, released in early March, midsize non-luxury cars didn't fare much better. A Nissan product was the worst performer in those tests as well with the Nissan Maxima suffering a total of $9,051 worth of damage.
    Many luxury and non-luxury cars suffer from the same problems, according to the Institute: bumpers that are simply too weak, impact absorbing structures that don't extend far enough to the corners and bumpers that are designed with visual appeal rather than damage control as the top priority.
    Underneath body-colored plastic exteriors, most bumpers have metal beams that are supposed to absorb crash forces. These beams can be too weak or not placed where needed to adequately protect against various types of impacts.
    In some cases, the Institute said, car bumpers can slide under the bumper of another vehicle during an impact, exposing headlights, grills and body sheet metal to damage.
    Luxury cars have the additional problem of expensive replacement parts. A headlight for a Lexus ES costs $1,046, according to the Institute. (Headlights were damaged in 15 or the 22 front impact tests the Institute conducted.) The front bumper cover for an Audi A4, one of the best performing vehicles in the tests, costs nearly $600, according to the Institute. That doesn't include installation and painting costs. View attachment 122590
    Luxury car bumper tests Estimated repair costs following Insurance Institute for Highway Safety bumper tests Test Front full width Front corner Rear full width Rear corner Total damage Saab 9-3 $1,476 $1,076 $1,722 $969 $5,243 Audi A4 $976 $2,038 $918 $1,899 $5,831 Lincoln MKZ $1,001 $1,966 $2,330 $669 $5,966 BMW 3-series $3,658 $1,256 $989 $778 $6,681 Acura TSX $1,693 $1,274 $3,430 $1,157 $7,554 Volvo S60 $4,517 $543 $2,142 $1,022 $8,224 Lexus IS $4965 $2,223 $1,922 $737 $9,577 Lexus ES $3,921 $2,093 $3,709 $1,101 $10,824 Mercedes-Benz C-class $5,486 $963 $3,728 $877 $11,054 Acura TL $4,985 $1,244 $3,814 $1,156 $11,199 Infinit G35 $5,223 $3,544 $4,035 $1,181 $13,983

     *Registered members do not see this ad, register today!

  2. gto

    gto Track Ready Moderator

    Likes Received:
    Los Angeles, CA
    05 FX35 RWD
    Crazy that that damage would amoun t to a 1/3 of the car total. Well, I can attest that the FX headlight was $1150- of my $3700- pole incident.
  3. Dr.2K

    Dr.2K iS Doctor on Duty iS VIP

    Likes Received:
    Santa Clarita, CA
    2005 FX45
    Intersesting...I guess infiniti better beef up those parts.
  4. brown_fv

    brown_fv Premium Member Premium

    Likes Received:
    Toronto, On
    wow...i thought infiniti's got high crash test rating...i think just last week i heard the M had one of the worst side impact damages or something like that.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.